← All voters

John Fay

Outlet
Cincinnati Enquirer (as of 2020)
Chapter
CIN
Public HOF ballots
8 (2015–2023)
Award ballots
10 (2012–2020)

Tendencies

Names per HOF ballot
8.0
public ballots avg 7.5
Full 10-name ballots
3 of 8
Backed that year’s electees
94%
share of BBWAA electees on ballot
1st-place vote won the award
9 of 10
all BBWAA awards
Picks no one else made
1
across 10 award ballots
WAR match
90%
−1 pts vs. median voter · ahead of 30% of voters

Hall of Fame ballots

Filled dot: voted for. Open dot: on the ballot but left off. Lists everyone this voter backed, plus inducted or 20%+ candidates they passed on. Public ballots from Ryan Thibodaux’s BBHOF Tracker. Names in red got under 5% of public ballots. In the “Names on ballot” row, 0 is a blank ballot (submitted with no names) and – means no public ballot that year: the voter may not have voted, or kept the ballot private.

Names on ballot101010–97684
Candidate201520162017201820192020202120222023
Curt Schilling·
Barry Bonds·
Larry WalkerHOF···
Roger Clemens·
Scott RolenHOF···
Mike MussinaHOF····
Edgar MartinezHOF····
Gary Sheffield
Jeff BagwellHOF·····
Tim RainesHOF·····
Billy WagnerHOF·
Trevor HoffmanHOF······
Andruw JonesHOF···
Omar Vizquel···
Alan TrammellHOF (era cmte.)······
Craig BiggioHOF·······
Jeff KentHOF (era cmte.)
John SmoltzHOF·······
Mike PiazzaHOF······
Pedro MartinezHOF·······
Randy JohnsonHOF·······
Ken Griffey Jr.HOF·······
Ivan RodriguezHOF·······
Manny Ramirez····
Mariano RiveraHOF·······
Roy HalladayHOF·······
Derek JeterHOF·······
Fred McGriffHOF (era cmte.)····
Lee SmithHOF (era cmte.)·····
Todd HeltonHOF···
Álex Rodríguez······
Manny Ramírez······

MVP ballots

Picked the winner first on 4 of 4 ballots. Average WAR match 88%.

Each pick
Where the player finished in the final vote, in bold when well off this voter’s spot. “Only voter” marks a pick no one else made.
fWAR · #rank
His FanGraphs WAR and rank among eligible players: red when he’s on the WAR ballot, blue when he’s well outside it.
WAR ballot
The top players by fWAR among those eligible: everyone for MVP, pitchers for Cy Young, rookies for Rookie of the Year, relievers for Reliever.
WAR match
The ballot’s fWAR, weighted by award points, as a share of the WAR ballot’s.
Ballots from bbwaa.com, WAR from FanGraphs.
Year12345678910
2020 NL
Cincinnati Enquirer
92% WAR match
finished 1
3.0 · #2
finished 2
2.7 · #5
finished 4
3.3 · #1
finished 8
1.9 · #32
finished 6
2.6 · #7
finished 7
2.8 · #4
finished 3
2.7 · #6
finished 12
2.2 · #18
finished 15
2.1 · #20
only voter · finished 20
1.4 · #56
WAR ballotFernando Tatis Jr. 3.3Freddie Freeman 3.0Yu Darvish 2.9Trea Turner 2.8Mookie Betts 2.7Manny Machado 2.7Marcell Ozuna 2.6Jacob deGrom 2.6Trevor Bauer 2.6Juan Soto 2.5
2018 NL
Cincinnati Enquirer
78% WAR match
finished 1
7.7 · #3
finished 2
5.8 · #7
finished 4
4.6 · #17
finished 3
6.0 · #6
finished 6
4.6 · #16
finished 9
4.1 · #25
finished 14
4.1 · #24
finished 7
6.0 · #5
finished 11
5.5 · #8
finished 19
4.4 · #20
WAR ballotJacob deGrom 9.4Max Scherzer 8.2Christian Yelich 7.7Patrick Corbin 6.1Lorenzo Cain 6.0Nolan Arenado 6.0Javier Báez 5.8Anthony Rendon 5.5Yasmani Grandal 5.3Trea Turner 5.1
2015 NL
Cincinnati Enquirer
89% WAR match
finished 1
9.3 · #1
finished 2
7.2 · #5
finished 7
6.0 · #11
finished 6
7.3 · #3
finished 3
7.3 · #4
finished 13
2.6 · #69
finished 5
6.0 · #12
finished 4
5.2 · #17
finished 12
5.3 · #16
finished 9
6.8 · #7
WAR ballotBryce Harper 9.3Clayton Kershaw 8.6Jake Arrieta 7.3Joey Votto 7.3Paul Goldschmidt 7.2Max Scherzer 6.9Buster Posey 6.8AJ Pollock 6.8Kris Bryant 6.1Madison Bumgarner 6.1
2013 NL
Cincinnati Enquirer
93% WAR match
finished 1
8.1 · #1
finished 2
6.0 · #11
finished 7
7.8 · #2
finished 3
7.2 · #4
finished 6
5.7 · #13
finished 4
7.2 · #3
finished 5
5.0 · #15
finished 8
4.9 · #17
finished 9
6.7 · #5
finished 10
4.0 · #33
WAR ballotAndrew McCutchen 8.1Clayton Kershaw 7.8Matt Carpenter 7.2Yadier Molina 7.2Carlos Gómez 6.7Buster Posey 6.7Matt Harvey 6.6Jonathan Lucroy 6.6Adam Wainwright 6.6Shin-Soo Choo 6.4

Cy Young ballots

Picked the winner first on 2 of 3 ballots. Average WAR match 90%.

Year12345
2019 NL
Cincinnati Enquirer
88% WAR match
finished 1
6.9 · #1
finished 4
4.7 · #7
finished 6
4.0 · #13
finished 2
5.0 · #5
finished 7
4.5 · #9
WAR ballotJacob deGrom 6.9Max Scherzer 6.5Stephen Strasburg 5.6Walker Buehler 5.1Hyun Jin Ryu 5.0
2014 NL
Cincinnati Enquirer
97% WAR match
finished 1
7.9 · #1
finished 2
4.4 · #8
finished 3
4.9 · #4
finished 5
5.4 · #2
finished 9
5.3 · #3
WAR ballotClayton Kershaw 7.9Jordan Zimmermann 5.4Jake Arrieta 5.3Adam Wainwright 4.9Stephen Strasburg 4.5
2012 NL
Cincinnati Enquirer
86% WAR match
finished 4
4.3 · #6
finished 1
4.7 · #4
finished 2
6.1 · #1
finished 7
3.3 · #13
finished 3
5.0 · #2
WAR ballotClayton Kershaw 6.1Gio Gonzalez 5.0Cliff Lee 5.0R.A. Dickey 4.7Cole Hamels 4.6

Rookie of the Year ballots

Picked the winner first on 2 of 2 ballots. Average WAR match 95%.

Year123
2017 NL
wcpo.com
95% WAR match
finished 1
4.0 · #1
finished 2
2.0 · #7
finished 5
2.4 · #3
WAR ballotCody Bellinger 4.0Manuel Margot 2.5Germán Márquez 2.4
2016 NL
wcpo.com
95% WAR match
finished 1
5.3 · #1
finished 5
3.1 · #5
finished 2
4.0 · #2
WAR ballotCorey Seager 5.3Trea Turner 4.0Jon Gray 3.5

Manager of the Year ballots

Picked the winner first on 1 of 1 ballot.

Year123
2013 NL
Cincinnati Enquirer
Clint Hurdle
finished 1
Don Mattingly
finished 2
Mike Matheny
finished 4

Votes most like John’s

Share of Hall of Fame yes/no calls that match, on candidates both voters had on the same ballot.