John Fay
- Outlet
- Cincinnati Enquirer (as of 2020)
- Chapter
- CIN
- Public HOF ballots
- 8 (2015–2023)
- Award ballots
- 10 (2012–2020)
Tendencies
- Names per HOF ballot
- 8.0
- public ballots avg 7.5
- Full 10-name ballots
- 3 of 8
- Backed that year’s electees
- 94%
- share of BBWAA electees on ballot
- 1st-place vote won the award
- 9 of 10
- all BBWAA awards
- Picks no one else made
- 1
- across 10 award ballots
- WAR match
- 90%
- −1 pts vs. median voter · ahead of 30% of voters
Hall of Fame ballots
Filled dot: voted for. Open dot: on the ballot but left off. Lists everyone this voter backed, plus inducted or 20%+ candidates they passed on. Public ballots from Ryan Thibodaux’s BBHOF Tracker. Names in red got under 5% of public ballots. In the “Names on ballot” row, 0 is a blank ballot (submitted with no names) and – means no public ballot that year: the voter may not have voted, or kept the ballot private.
| Names on ballot | 10 | 10 | 10 | – | 9 | 7 | 6 | 8 | 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Candidate | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 |
| Curt Schilling | · | ||||||||
| Barry Bonds | · | ||||||||
| Larry WalkerHOF | · | · | · | ||||||
| Roger Clemens | · | ||||||||
| Scott RolenHOF | · | · | · | ||||||
| Mike MussinaHOF | · | · | · | · | |||||
| Edgar MartinezHOF | · | · | · | · | |||||
| Gary Sheffield | |||||||||
| Jeff BagwellHOF | · | · | · | · | · | ||||
| Tim RainesHOF | · | · | · | · | · | ||||
| Billy WagnerHOF | · | ||||||||
| Trevor HoffmanHOF | · | · | · | · | · | · | |||
| Andruw JonesHOF | · | · | · | ||||||
| Omar Vizquel | · | · | · | ||||||
| Alan TrammellHOF (era cmte.) | · | · | · | · | · | · | |||
| Craig BiggioHOF | · | · | · | · | · | · | · | ||
| Jeff KentHOF (era cmte.) | |||||||||
| John SmoltzHOF | · | · | · | · | · | · | · | ||
| Mike PiazzaHOF | · | · | · | · | · | · | |||
| Pedro MartinezHOF | · | · | · | · | · | · | · | ||
| Randy JohnsonHOF | · | · | · | · | · | · | · | ||
| Ken Griffey Jr.HOF | · | · | · | · | · | · | · | ||
| Ivan RodriguezHOF | · | · | · | · | · | · | · | ||
| Manny Ramirez | · | · | · | · | |||||
| Mariano RiveraHOF | · | · | · | · | · | · | · | ||
| Roy HalladayHOF | · | · | · | · | · | · | · | ||
| Derek JeterHOF | · | · | · | · | · | · | · | ||
| Fred McGriffHOF (era cmte.) | · | · | · | · | |||||
| Lee SmithHOF (era cmte.) | · | · | · | · | · | ||||
| Todd HeltonHOF | · | · | · | ||||||
| Álex Rodríguez | · | · | · | · | · | · | |||
| Manny Ramírez | · | · | · | · | · | · |
- 2023
Andruw Jones, Scott Rolen, Gary Sheffield, Billy Wagner
4 names · backed 1 of 1 elected · made public Feb 7, 2023 · via BBWAA.com
- 2022
Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, Andruw Jones, Scott Rolen, Curt Schilling, Gary Sheffield, Omar Vizquel, Billy Wagner
8 names · backed 0 of 1 elected · made public Feb 8, 2022 · via BBWAA.com
- 2021
Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, Scott Rolen, Curt Schilling, Gary Sheffield, Omar Vizquel
6 names · made public Nov 24, 2020 · via Cinci Enquirer
- 2020
Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, Derek Jeter, Manny Ramirez, Scott Rolen, Curt Schilling, Larry Walker
7 names · backed 2 of 2 elected · made public Feb 4, 2020 · via BBWAA.com
- 2019
Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, Roy Halladay, Edgar Martinez, Mike Mussina, Mariano Rivera, Scott Rolen, Curt Schilling, Larry Walker
9 names · backed 4 of 4 elected · made public Jan 8, 2019 · via Reds Beat Podcast · not public last year
- 2017
Jeff Bagwell, Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, Trevor Hoffman, Edgar Martinez, Mike Mussina, Tim Raines, Ivan Rodriguez, Curt Schilling, Larry Walker
10 names · backed 3 of 3 elected · made public Dec 30, 2016 · via WCPO.com
- 2016
Jeff Bagwell, Ken Griffey Jr., Trevor Hoffman, Edgar Martinez, Mike Mussina, Mike Piazza, Tim Raines, Curt Schilling, Alan Trammell, Larry Walker
10 names · backed 2 of 2 elected · made public Jan 6, 2016 · source
- 2015
Jeff Bagwell, Craig Biggio, Randy Johnson, Jeff Kent, Pedro Martinez, Mike Mussina, Tim Raines, Curt Schilling, John Smoltz, Larry Walker
10 names · backed 4 of 4 elected · made public Jan 6, 2015 · source
MVP ballots
Picked the winner first on 4 of 4 ballots. Average WAR match 88%.
- Each pick
- Where the player finished in the final vote, in bold when well off this voter’s spot. “Only voter” marks a pick no one else made.
- fWAR · #rank
- His FanGraphs WAR and rank among eligible players: red when he’s on the WAR ballot, blue when he’s well outside it.
- WAR ballot
- The top players by fWAR among those eligible: everyone for MVP, pitchers for Cy Young, rookies for Rookie of the Year, relievers for Reliever.
- WAR match
- The ballot’s fWAR, weighted by award points, as a share of the WAR ballot’s.
| Year | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 NL Cincinnati Enquirer 92% WAR match | finished 1 3.0 · #2 | finished 2 2.7 · #5 | finished 4 3.3 · #1 | finished 8 1.9 · #32 | finished 6 2.6 · #7 | finished 7 2.8 · #4 | finished 3 2.7 · #6 | finished 12 2.2 · #18 | finished 15 2.1 · #20 | only voter · finished 20 1.4 · #56 |
| WAR ballot | Fernando Tatis Jr. 3.3 | Freddie Freeman 3.0 | Yu Darvish 2.9 | Trea Turner 2.8 | Mookie Betts 2.7 | Manny Machado 2.7 | Marcell Ozuna 2.6 | Jacob deGrom 2.6 | Trevor Bauer 2.6 | Juan Soto 2.5 |
| 2018 NL Cincinnati Enquirer 78% WAR match | finished 1 7.7 · #3 | finished 2 5.8 · #7 | finished 4 4.6 · #17 | finished 3 6.0 · #6 | finished 6 4.6 · #16 | finished 9 4.1 · #25 | finished 14 4.1 · #24 | finished 7 6.0 · #5 | finished 11 5.5 · #8 | finished 19 4.4 · #20 |
| WAR ballot | Jacob deGrom 9.4 | Max Scherzer 8.2 | Christian Yelich 7.7 | Patrick Corbin 6.1 | Lorenzo Cain 6.0 | Nolan Arenado 6.0 | Javier Báez 5.8 | Anthony Rendon 5.5 | Yasmani Grandal 5.3 | Trea Turner 5.1 |
| 2015 NL Cincinnati Enquirer 89% WAR match | finished 1 9.3 · #1 | finished 2 7.2 · #5 | finished 7 6.0 · #11 | finished 6 7.3 · #3 | finished 3 7.3 · #4 | finished 13 2.6 · #69 | finished 5 6.0 · #12 | finished 4 5.2 · #17 | finished 12 5.3 · #16 | finished 9 6.8 · #7 |
| WAR ballot | Bryce Harper 9.3 | Clayton Kershaw 8.6 | Jake Arrieta 7.3 | Joey Votto 7.3 | Paul Goldschmidt 7.2 | Max Scherzer 6.9 | Buster Posey 6.8 | AJ Pollock 6.8 | Kris Bryant 6.1 | Madison Bumgarner 6.1 |
| 2013 NL Cincinnati Enquirer 93% WAR match | finished 1 8.1 · #1 | finished 2 6.0 · #11 | finished 7 7.8 · #2 | finished 3 7.2 · #4 | finished 6 5.7 · #13 | finished 4 7.2 · #3 | finished 5 5.0 · #15 | finished 8 4.9 · #17 | finished 9 6.7 · #5 | finished 10 4.0 · #33 |
| WAR ballot | Andrew McCutchen 8.1 | Clayton Kershaw 7.8 | Matt Carpenter 7.2 | Yadier Molina 7.2 | Carlos Gómez 6.7 | Buster Posey 6.7 | Matt Harvey 6.6 | Jonathan Lucroy 6.6 | Adam Wainwright 6.6 | Shin-Soo Choo 6.4 |
Cy Young ballots
Picked the winner first on 2 of 3 ballots. Average WAR match 90%.
| Year | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 NL Cincinnati Enquirer 88% WAR match | finished 1 6.9 · #1 | finished 4 4.7 · #7 | finished 6 4.0 · #13 | finished 2 5.0 · #5 | finished 7 4.5 · #9 |
| WAR ballot | Jacob deGrom 6.9 | Max Scherzer 6.5 | Stephen Strasburg 5.6 | Walker Buehler 5.1 | Hyun Jin Ryu 5.0 |
| 2014 NL Cincinnati Enquirer 97% WAR match | finished 1 7.9 · #1 | finished 2 4.4 · #8 | finished 3 4.9 · #4 | finished 5 5.4 · #2 | finished 9 5.3 · #3 |
| WAR ballot | Clayton Kershaw 7.9 | Jordan Zimmermann 5.4 | Jake Arrieta 5.3 | Adam Wainwright 4.9 | Stephen Strasburg 4.5 |
| 2012 NL Cincinnati Enquirer 86% WAR match | finished 4 4.3 · #6 | finished 1 4.7 · #4 | finished 2 6.1 · #1 | finished 7 3.3 · #13 | finished 3 5.0 · #2 |
| WAR ballot | Clayton Kershaw 6.1 | Gio Gonzalez 5.0 | Cliff Lee 5.0 | R.A. Dickey 4.7 | Cole Hamels 4.6 |
Rookie of the Year ballots
Picked the winner first on 2 of 2 ballots. Average WAR match 95%.
Manager of the Year ballots
Picked the winner first on 1 of 1 ballot.
| Year | 1 | 2 | 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2013 NL Cincinnati Enquirer | Clint Hurdle finished 1 | Don Mattingly finished 2 | Mike Matheny finished 4 |
Votes most like John’s
Share of Hall of Fame yes/no calls that match, on candidates both voters had on the same ballot.
- Peter Barzilai93% of 188
- Scott Bordow92% of 137
- Jeff Jacobs92% of 194
- Peter Gammons91% of 252
- Sam Mellinger91% of 126