Sandbagged: Five Myths About Bat Speed
It's like I'm not swinging, hard at all, hard at all...

Isaac Paredes has one of the most famous swings in baseball for a pretty specific reason: he pulls fly balls to left field better than almost anyone alive, and he has built an entire career out of dropping them just over the closest fence in the park. I wrote about it in I-Sack of Pulled Potatoes, and so have many others, because once you see the spray chart you cannot unsee it.

Paredes’ 117 career homers all to the pull side
What almost nobody writes about is how hard he swings, or more to the point, how hard he chooses not to. Paredes's normal swing in 2026 was 66.5 mph, one of the ten slowest among regulars, a good five mph under the typical big leaguer. His hardest swings, though, reach almost 76 mph, faster than a typical big leaguer's normal swing. The gap between Paredes's everyday swing and his best swing is the second largest in baseball. He has a secret 7th gear, he just never shifts into it most of the time. I am calling that gap the Sandbag: how much faster a hitter's hardest swings (his top 5%) are than his normal one. And once you start measuring it, a lot of what we think we know about bat speed starts to wobble. So instead of the usual tour, here are five myths about bat speed and the truths hiding behind them.
Quick Note: Raw bat speed depends a lot on where the pitch is, since everyone swings slower at a pitch on the outside corner than one down the middle (I wrote about it in Fast Times At Bat Speed High). So unless I say otherwise, the numbers here use paBS (point-adjusted bat speed), which compares every swing to what a typical hitter does on a pitch in that same spot. And the Sandbag is measured only on swings at pitches in the strike zone, for reasons that will become very clear in Myth #2.
Myth #1: A hitter has a bat speed
Truth: He has a range.
We talk about bat speed like it is a fixed trait, one number on the back of a baseball card next to the home runs and the walk rate. But every hitter carries a whole range of swings, and the size of that range is a trait in its own right. The typical hitter's hardest swings in the zone run about five and a half mph faster than his normal one. At the top of the list, Evan Carter's gap is 10.5 mph, which means his best swing and his everyday swing are practically two different hitters. Paredes is second at 8.6, followed by Michael Conforto, Christian Encarnacion-Strand, Jesús Sánchez, Ketel Marte and Brandon Nimmo. At the other end are the hitters who bring the same swing every single time: Chandler Simpson (3.5), Jared Triolo, Mike Yastrzemski and Taylor Walls. Simpson's hardest swing is barely faster than his normal one, which tracks for a guy whose entire game is putting the ball on the ground and running.

The important part is that the Sandbag has nothing to do with how hard a hitter swings on average. Fast swingers and slow swingers carry about the same spread, so a big Sandbag is not just a big swing with extra noise. Marte's normal swing in the zone is about 74 mph and his best is over 82. Paredes lives eight mph lower and still has almost the same gap. It also holds up over the season: hitters with a big gap in the first half tend to have a big gap in the second half. It is a habit, and like most habits it says something about what a hitter is trying to do. For what it's worth, it barely shows up at the team level. The spread between the most sandbagged lineup (San Diego) and the least (the White Sox) is only about a mph, which is close to what you would get by shuffling hitters onto teams at random. The White Sox are a fun illustration all the same: they have the best Decision+ (my grade for swing decisions, 100 is average) in baseball and are tied for the lowest Contact+ (my grade for making contact on the pitches a hitter swings at, 100 is average). A lineup that picks good pitches and then swings out of its shoes at every one of them.
Myth #2: A slow bat means a weak swing
Truth: Some of it is chasing.
Here is something that seems obvious once you say it out loud but has a real effect on the numbers everyone looks at. Swings at pitches outside the zone are slower than swings at pitches inside it, for everyone. A hitter reaching for a slider off the plate is not trying to hit it 110 mph; he is trying to foul it off and live another pitch. Across the league, the typical swing at a pitch in the zone was 72.3 mph this season and the typical swing at a pitch outside it was 70.5. That means a hitter who chases a lot gets dinged on raw bat speed for swings that were never meant to be hard in the first place.
How much does it matter? Count only the swings at pitches in the zone and the typical hitter's normal swing goes up by about half a mph. For the heaviest chasers it is closer to a mph and a half, and the size of the bump lines up closely with how often a hitter expands the zone. Some of the hitters who gain the most are names you would not think of as having a bat speed problem at all: Cal Raleigh and Junior Caminero both gain about 1.3 mph, and James Wood and Shohei Ohtani gain about 1.25 mph. On the other side are the hitters who rarely chase and therefore lose nothing, like Steven Kwan, TJ Friedl and J.P. Crawford, whose raw bat speed is already a clean read on their real swing.

This is the whole reason paBS exists. Because it compares each swing to what a typical hitter does in that same location, a slow swing at a pitch a foot off the plate gets graded against other swings at pitches a foot off the plate. Adjusted that way, a hitter's bat speed barely moves whether you count his chases or not. So if you are looking at a raw leaderboard and wondering why a slugger like Raleigh sits lower than you expected, part of the answer is the pitches he swings at, not the swing itself. Chasing still leaves one fingerprint even after the adjustment, though, and it shows up in the Sandbag. Hold that thought for Myth #4.
Myth #3: Hitters shorten up with two strikes
Truth: Mostly, the pitches move.
Every hitter is taught to choke up and protect with two strikes, and raw bat speed seems to show it. Across the league, hitters swing about two mph slower with two strikes than before two strikes. Earlier this summer I used exactly that measure to sort hitters into Swing Away Merrills (who keep swinging hard with two strikes) and Shy Away Dereks (who ease off). But here is the catch: two-strike pitches are not thrown in the same places as other pitches. Pitchers ahead in the count go away, go down and go off the plate, which are exactly the spots where everyone swings slower. Once you adjust for where the pitch was, the real two-strike drop shrinks to about 1.4 mph, and how much a hitter shortens up has no relationship with how much contact he makes.

That does not mean nobody shortens up. Some hitters really do take something off with two strikes even after the adjustment, and the cleaner version of the measure still sorts them nicely. The real Shy Away Dereks of 2026 include Bo Bichette (3.2 mph slower with two strikes), Gleyber Torres (3.1), Royce Lewis (2.9), Adley Rutschman (2.7) and, once again, Shohei Ohtani (2.8), who has one of the biggest swings in the sport and still takes a little off when the count turns. Oneil Cruz, who has the fastest normal swing of anyone in that group, also eases off by about 2.6 mph. Austin Hedges is the most extreme at about six mph, which surprises nobody who has watched him hit with two strikes. Paredes is right in that group at about 3.1.
On the other side, the Swing Away Merrills who keep swinging at full speed with two strikes, or even swing harder: Roman Anthony actually speeds up, Colson Montgomery and Pedro Pagés are still on the list from that piece, and Jasson Domínguez, Hunter Goodman and Yandy Díaz all bring the same swing regardless of the count. And in what has to be the best result in this entire piece, the list also includes an actual Merrill. Jackson Merrill swings just as hard with two strikes as he does with none.
Myth #4: A hitter who could swing harder is leaving value on the table
Truth: The Sandbag is a style, not a skill.
If Paredes can swing 76 mph, why does he spend most of his time at 66? The intuitive read is that he is leaving power on the table, and that a hitter with a big Sandbag would be better if he just let it rip more often. The data does not back that up. Holding a hitter's normal bat speed constant, the size of his Sandbag in the zone has no relationship with his overall Hitting+ (my overall hitting grade, 100 is average), his Decision+, or his Power+ (my grade for bat speed and attack angle adjusted for pitch location). The only grade it leans toward is Contact+, at under a point per mph of Sandbag, and even that is small enough that I would not bet on it. Hitters with a big gap are not better or worse. They are just doing something different.

There is a trap here worth pointing out, because it is the same chasing effect from Myth #2. If you measure the Sandbag on every swing instead of just swings in the zone, big-gap hitters suddenly look like worse decision makers. That is because hitters who chase more take more slow, defensive swings at pitches off the plate, which drags their normal swing down and stretches the gap up to their best swing. Measure it in the zone and the link to decisions disappears completely. So a big Sandbag on a raw leaderboard can mean a hitter is choosing not to swing all-out, or it can just mean he flails at a lot of sliders. Only the first one is the interesting kind.
None of this means swinging hard does not matter. When a hitter does turn it up, it pays. Across the league, a hitter's hardest fifth of swings produce about five mph more exit velocity on contact than the rest of his swings, at the cost of about three more whiffs per hundred swings. For Paredes the trade is even better: his hard swings come with about seven more mph of exit velocity and he actually misses less on them (11.7% whiffs on his hardest fifth, 14.4% on everything else). The extra gear is real. What the data says is that having more of it in reserve does not, by itself, make a hitter better.
Myth #5: The secret is knowing when to turn it up
Truth: Picking your spots is a profile, not an edge.
So if the size of the Sandbag does not matter, maybe what matters is when a hitter uses it. This is the version of the story I most wanted to be true, because Paredes is such a clean example. He swings hardest when he is ahead in the count (68.2 mph on his typical swing) and softest with two strikes (63.6). He swings harder on pitches on the inner third of the plate (68.1) than on the outer third (64.8). That is a hitter turning the dial up exactly when he gets a pitch he can pull into the Crawford Boxes and down when he is just trying to survive. He is about as selective with his effort as anyone in baseball, in the 95th percentile of regulars.

But across the league, picking your spots turns out to be a profile rather than a secret. Take two hitters with the same normal swing and the same size Sandbag, one who saves his hard swings for hitter's counts and inside pitches and one who spreads them around. The picker does not make more contact. What he does have is less power. Hitters with a big gap who pick their spots averaged a Contact+ of 105 and a Power+ of 95. Hitters with a big gap who spread their hard swings around averaged 101 and 105. Their overall Hitting+ and their xwOBA (expected weighted on-base average, a measure of overall production based on quality of contact) came out about the same. They get to the same place by different roads.

Paredes is the poster child for the picker profile: elite contact (a Contact+ of 120) with below-average power (Power+ 86), and an overall Hitting+ right around average. Ketel Marte is the reminder that it is not the only way to get there: He has nearly the same size Sandbag as Paredes, barely changes his effort by count or location (he is in the 34th percentile for picking his spots), and still has elite contact to go with big power. And Evan Carter, with the biggest gap in baseball, sits right in the middle on picking his spots and has a Contact+ of 87.5. The gap alone does not make the hitter, and neither does when he uses it.
So here is where Paredes leaves us. The pull-air swing gets all the attention, but the more defining thing about him is a choice he makes on every pitch about how much of his swing to use. His normal swing sits eight or nine mph below his best, and when he gets a pitch on the inner half in a hitter's count, he lets it go. That choice does not make him better than a hitter who swings all-out every time. It makes him a different kind of hitter, one who trades thump for contact on purpose, and then uses the thump he keeps on the exact pitches that end up in the Crawford Boxes.
The Short Version
Hitters do not have a bat speed, they have a range. The typical gap between a hitter's normal swing and his hardest is about five and a half mph, from Chandler Simpson's 3.5 to Evan Carter's 10.5.
Raw bat speed undersells chasers. Swings at pitches off the plate are slower for everyone, and removing them lifts heavy chasers like Cal Raleigh and Junior Caminero by more than a mph.
Most of the famous two-strike slowdown is pitchers throwing to slower spots. The real Shy Away Dereks (Bichette, Ohtani, Rutschman) and Swing Away Merrills (Anthony, Montgomery, and yes, Jackson Merrill) still stand out.
The Sandbag is a style, not a skill. It has no relationship with Hitting+ once you measure it on pitches in the zone.
Picking your spots is a profile, not an edge. Hitters who save their hard swings for the right counts and locations trade power for contact and end up in about the same place.