Rise of the Kitchen Sink Starters

Let that sink in

This is a followup to an interaction I had with Ben Palmer back in July 2023 when he posted the article How is Dane Dunning Doing This?:

A few years ago, the mainstay philosophy for pitchers was the flow chart saying:

“Are you Yu Darvish?” — No —> “Just Throw your Best Pitch Idiot”

and pitchers like Mitch Keller and Chris Bassitt were considered to be the outliers.

Fast forward to 2024, and it seems every night we are seeing a starter twirl a gem using their “deep arsenal”

but is it that just perception, or are there more starters are using this “deep arsenal”?

To evaluate this, I looked at every starter with +60 IP thrown before the All Star Break since 2017, and from there I looked at the starters who had a better than average ERA compared to the rest of the league (since we don’t care about the guys throwing 5 pitches that are getting killed). From there, I checked the # of pitches those “above-average starters” were throwing more than 5% of the time. Here are the results:

So between 2017-2019 there were only two above-average starter who used 6-pitches or more (Aníbal Sánchez and a certain former Dodgers suspended creep), but in 2024, there are now ten above-average starters using +6 pitches, and for two of them (Seth Lugo and Michael Lorenzen), they are using 7 different pitches.

What’s even more interesting about this trend, it’s not just that we are seeing pitchers be effective by using more pitches (like Sean Manaea or Seth Lugo), we are seeing already effective starters choose to add pitches to their repertoire. Here are the 10 above-average starters throwing +6 pitches in 2024, and how many pitches they had in prior seasons:

So as evidenced above, there are effective starters who have gone from being 3-pitch pitchers all the way to 6-pitch pitchers, which would have been a hard to predict trend back in 2017 when streamlining your arsenal was seen as "being smart”.

Get Balls & Sticks in your inbox

Subscribe for free to get new posts by email as soon as they publish.