Mood Swings+

Analyzing how Hitting+ components change in-season

Mood Swings+

This is the third part of the Hitting+ series. Part one can be read here and part two here.

Last time I followed hitters across their careers and found a clean split: plate discipline barely moves from a hitter's early twenties to his late thirties, while the power in his swing wears down at about a third of a point a year. The bat may go, but the eye stays. If you are new here, the grades are built on the swing itself, in four pieces: Decision+ for whether to swing, Timing+ for when the bat arrived, Contact+ for whether it found the ball, and Power+ for what the swing brought. They roll into Hitting+, where 100 is league average and 15 points is one standard deviation, calibrated against xwOBA (expected weighted on-base average, what a hitter deserved from the quality of his contact before luck on balls in play gets involved). Spend enough time on the player pages at the site and something jumps out that looks like part two turned upside down. Within a season, the Power+ line sits nearly flat from April to September, while Decision+ rises and falls all summer. Across a career the eye holds and the bat fades, and inside a season it looks like the bat holds and the eye has moods. The question for this piece is what those moods actually are.

Pete Alonso rolling component chart

Here’s a rolling graph for Pete Alonso in 2026 as an example

The Consistent Bat

Cut every season into quarters and grade each quarter on its own, for every hitter with at least 150 plate appearances from 2024 through 2026. From one quarter to the next, the typical hitter's Power+ moves 5.4 points, about a third of a standard deviation. That is the flat line you see on the site, and it is flat for a simple reason. Power+ is measured on every swing a hitter takes and settles on his true level in a couple dozen swings, so a quarter of a season, a few hundred pitches, is more than enough to pin it down. When Power+ does move from one quarter to the next, about a third of that movement is the hitter's swing actually changing, which is a far higher share than any other component.

The Shifting Eye

Decision+ is a different story. It moves about three times as much as Power+ from one part of the season to the next, and Timing+ and Contact+ bounce around more than Power+ too. But that doesn't mean the hitter is changing. Picture a hitter going through a tough few weeks: a run of good pitchers, a lot of borderline pitches on the corners, a couple of series in parks that play against him. Then picture an easy few weeks, full of obvious balls, pitches down the middle and friendlier parks. Every swing decision is graded against the pitch it was made on, so the exact same eye grades very differently in those two stretches, and it takes far more pitches than a hitter sees in a few weeks for those stretches to even out. Nearly all of the ups and downs in Decision+ come from the pitches a hitter happened to see, not from the hitter. The same goes for most of the movement in Timing+ and Contact+.

Rafael Devers in 2026 is what that looks like on a page. His Power+ stayed between 99 and 109 in all four quarters of the season. His Decision+ went 111, 77, 102 and 76. Nothing about Devers changed four times in six months. What changed was the set of pitches each stretch handed him.

What Actually Moves

Strip the stretch of pitches out and ask how much each part of a hitter really changes, inside a season and from one season to the next, and the answer is not much on either clock. Inside a season, Power+ really moves about 3.2 points, Contact+ about 3.3, and Decision+ about 1.6, which is small enough that it cannot be told apart from no change at all. From season to season, Power+ really moves about 4.5 points, Contact+ 4.2 and Decision+ 3.7. Against a scale where one standard deviation is 15 points, the swing underneath barely moves in either direction. The one clear split between the clocks belongs to Power+, which moves more across seasons than within them, and that is part two's aging bat showing up again. The only piece with a hint of the opposite pattern is Timing+, which really moves about 5 points inside a season and less than 2 from year to year, a fit with the idea that a hitter's timing comes and goes over a summer, though that gap is too close to call with confidence.

So the flip on the player pages is real, but it is a flip in what you can see, not in what the hitter is doing. The bat reads fast, so its line shows you the hitter. The eye reads slow, so its line shows you the pitches.

The Stretch of Pitches

This is where the ups and downs come from. A hitter's swing is close to the same in May and in August, and what changes from one stretch to the next is the run of pitches he gets, the corners that week, the pitchers on the schedule, the mistakes that did or did not come over the plate. His decisions and contact are graded on those pitches and his results are built from them, so a good stretch of pitches reads as a hot streak in both, and a bad one reads as a slump. That is the mood in Mood Swings+. It belongs to the stretch, not the hitter.

Reading a Slump

This gives you a way to read a cold hitter. A dip in Decision+ or Contact+ over a few weeks is almost entirely the pitches he has seen, and the season-level grade is the one to trust. Power+ is different, because it reads fast enough that a real change shows up quickly and stays. Gunnar Henderson's 2026 Power+ went 120, 115, 112 and 110 across the four quarters of the season, a steady slide in the one grade that does not bounce around on its own, and that is the kind of move worth paying attention to. In the last week of the season, Henderson said he had been playing through a right wrist problem for about half the year, which lines up with the back half of that slide. The drop started a little before the wrist became an issue, so it is not the whole story, but it is the kind of thing a steady grade picks up long before a player says anything about it.

The Short Version

  1. On the player pages, Power+ stays nearly flat through a season while Decision+ rises and falls, the reverse of part two, where the eye held and the bat faded.

  2. Power+ reads fast. It settles in a couple dozen swings, so a few weeks of swings pin a hitter down.

  3. Decision+ reads slow. About 99 percent of its quarter-to-quarter movement is the stretch of pitches a hitter saw, not a change in him.

  4. Strip that out and the swing underneath barely moves, inside a season or between seasons. Power+ is the one part that clearly moves more over years than over months.

  5. A few weeks of bad decisions is the pitches. A steady slide in Power+ is worth watching.

Get Balls & Sticks in your inbox

Subscribe for free to get new posts by email as soon as they publish.