Let's Do the Stance Dance

Put on your ASICS and move your feet (two inches towards the plate).

Shall We Dance?

Jake Bauers came into 2026 standing in the box like a different hitter. His feet were much closer together than the year before, his stance had opened way up from a nearly square setup, and he had backed up in the box toward the catcher.

Bauers in 2026

Bauers in 2025

By Statcast's batting stance tracking it was the biggest stance change any regular made going into the season, and he did not treat it as an experiment: the new setup held in every month from April to September. The season that came with it was the best of his career. Bauers got 552 plate appearances after never topping 345 with the Brewers, pushed his hard-hit rate from 45.6% to 51.9%, kept his chase rate right around 21%, and finished with a wOBA (weighted on-base average, the all-in-one hitting rate that weights each outcome by what it is worth) of .382 and an xwOBA (expected wOBA, what his contact deserved before luck on balls in play) of .373. Compared with what a hitter with his 2025 line, age and playing time would normally do the next year, he beat expectation by 47 points of xwOBA. Brewer Fanatic's Cory Sparks wrote up the breakout in May, pointing to a flatter launch angle and three straight years in the same organization, and the new setup is the most visible part of that story.

There is one wrinkle worth knowing, and it comes from Hitting+, which grades the swing itself instead of the results in four pieces: Decision+ (whether to swing), Timing+ (when the bat arrived), Contact+ (whether it found the ball) and Power+ (what the swing brought). 100 is league average and 15 points is one standard deviation. Hitting+ liked Bauers before any of this happened. He graded at 118.6 in 2024 and 125.4 in a partial 2025, then 128.0 in 2026, and the stance change did not cost him anything the grade measures: his bat speed held at 76.5 mph and his Decision+ sat at 108.7 in both seasons. So the Bauers story is a good hitter who changed his setup, kept everything that made him good, and finally got enough at-bats for the results to show it. That is a real success. The question is how often it goes that way for anyone else.

Two Left Feet

Stance changes are not rare. Using Statcast's four stance measures (how far apart the feet are, how open or closed the stance is, how deep the hitter stands in the box, and how far off the plate), call it a real change when one of them moves more than 90% of normal year-to-year changes and well outside that hitter's own month-to-month wobble. By that bar, about one in five regulars changes his stance every offseason: 18% going into 2025 and 20% going into 2026, with another fifth of hitters showing a clear change in the middle of a season. The hitters who do it are not a random draw. They are coming off worse years, averaging a 98.7 Hitting+ and a .306 xwOBA the season before, against 103.0 and .321 for everyone who stood pat. A hitter who just had a bad year is due for some bounce-back no matter what he does with his feet, so a stance change arrives with a head start built in.

Take that head start away by comparing each changer with similar hitters who kept their stance (same prior season, age and playing time), and more than half of the improvement disappears. What is left is a trade, not a fix: stance changers gain a little power and give back a little contact. On average their Power+ rises about two points, their bat speed goes up 0.3 mph, and their hard-hit rate climbs 1.5 points, while their whiff rate (misses per swing) rises nearly a point. Net of all that, their Hitting+ improves by about one point, which is too small to tell apart from zero. Decision+ and Timing+ do not move at all, which fits what part two of the Hitting+ series found about aging: the eye stays put, and the bat is what changes.

The 2026 class shows the spread. Of the stance changers who got at least 150 plate appearances in both seasons, 28% beat expectation by 20 or more points of xwOBA, 52% landed within 20 points either way, and 20% fell short by 20 or more. Some of the misses made changes on Bauers' scale. José Tena narrowed his base and closed off his stance:

Tena in 2026

Tena in 2025

…and his Power+ jumped 23.5 points on 3.4 more mph of bat speed, but his Contact+ fell 25 points and his whiff rate rose 12 points, and his xwOBA ended up right where it started. That is the whole trade in one hitter. Eli White narrowed his base and landed on an April list of notable stance changes, and his xwOBA fell from .307 to .268. Tyler O'Neill moved deeper in the box and lost 1.6 mph of bat speed, with his xwOBA falling from .360 to .306. Colson Montgomery moved up in the box and his whiff rate went up six points. Then there are the hitters you do not see at all: 34 of the 88 hitters who changed stance going into 2026 never reached 150 plate appearances, including several who were everyday players in 2025. A stance change that does not work often ends with the hitter out of the lineup, and nobody writes that follow-up.

Which brings us to the stories that do get written. After hot Aprils, Sports Illustrated in 2025 and Athlon in 2026 ran pieces on hitters raking with new stances, and Bauers got his in May. Put every hitter from those after-the-fact stories next to the full list of changers and the gap is the whole problem in one number. The hitters in the stance-change stories beat expectation by 35 points of wOBA; the typical stance changer beat it by six. Preseason lists built from the stance data alone, like MLB.com's in April 2025 and Corbin Young's in April 2026, picked hitters by the size of the change instead of the results and landed at 13 points. The stance change you read about in May is not a typical stance change. It is the one that already worked.

Who's Leading?

If stance changes are this common, the natural suspicion is that teams are behind a lot of them. A hitter lands with a new club, meets a new hitting coach with a new philosophy, and shows up in spring standing differently. The data does not bear that out. Hitters who switched teams over the winter changed their stance 22% of the time, and hitters who stayed changed 21% of the time, and the rates were within about two points of each other in every offseason. A new team with the same stance did nothing for a hitter's numbers, and the small power gain showed up for stance changers whether or not they had moved. Deadline trades tell the same story: traded hitters were no more likely to change their stance in the middle of a season (21%) than hitters who stayed put (23%), with only a slight bump in changes landing in the same month as the trade.

Organizations do not stand out either. Over the last three offseasons, the Tigers (38%), White Sox (37%) and Brewers (34%) had the highest share of hitters who showed up in a new stance, and the Blue Jays, Phillies, Orioles and Cubs had the lowest (11%). That looks like a list of teams with a hitting philosophy until you notice the spread is about what chance alone would produce with 30 to 45 hitters per team, and that a team's rate in one year tells you nothing about its rate the next. There is no stance factory. Bauers fits the pattern too, since his change came in his third season in Milwaukee, with the same staff he had worked with since 2024. Stance changes look like something hitters decide for themselves, usually after a bad year.

Changing Partners

Jesús Sánchez went into 2026 with a narrower stance too, and on paper he looked like a Bauers candidate: a lefty-hitting corner outfielder, 28 years old, whose bat speed ranked in roughly the top 6% of regulars in 2025. But Sánchez's stance has not sat still for years. It closed up a good deal in 2024, spread out wider in the middle of 2025, and came back in narrower for 2026, as the chart below shows. That is a different setup three years running, and the teams kept changing around him just as fast: Miami traded him to Houston at the 2025 deadline, and Houston sent him to Toronto for Joey Loperfido in February, three clubs in eight months.

The 2026 version cost him. His bat speed fell from 75.9 mph to 73.6, his chase rate (swings at pitches outside the zone) jumped from 30.6% to 38.0%, one of the highest among regulars, his Power+ dropped 11 points and his Hitting+ fell from 122.6 to 99.7. What makes Sánchez worth a close look is that his results barely moved. His xwOBA went from .323 to .319, and a May run fueled by a .426 BABIP (batting average on balls in play) had him looking like one of the stance-change success stories for a few weeks, so he would never show up on anyone's list of stance changes gone wrong. The grade saw it anyway, and eventually so did the teams. Jays Journal notes he walked 2.5% of the time and struck out in 25.9% of his plate appearances. Toronto designated him for assignment on September 11, Arizona claimed him three days later, and the Diamondbacks designated him again on September 26 and sent him outright to Triple-A on the 29th.

Learn the Routine

Put Bauers and Sánchez side by side and the difference is not the stance. Both went narrower. The difference is that Bauers has been heading the same direction for four years, bringing his feet a little closer together every season before the big jump in 2026, and he held the 2026 version every month of the season. Sánchez's feet held steady, then spread out, then came back in. Bauers' Hitting+ has moved an average of 4.7 points from one season to the next; Sánchez's has moved 18.9.

That pattern holds well beyond these two. Call it stance drift: how much a hitter's setup moves around from month to month, averaged across the four stance measures. Among regulars with multiple qualified seasons, the hitters with the most stance drift see their Hitting+ swing by an average of 10.3 points from one year to the next, against 8.6 for the steadiest quarter, and the gap holds after accounting for playing time and age. A hitter whose setup keeps moving has a grade that keeps moving with it. The same idea shows up among the changers themselves. About three-quarters of them stayed on the new side of their change every month of the next season, and those hitters beat expectation by two points of Hitting+, while the ones who drifted back toward their old stance fell about a point and a half short. That split is not large enough to call settled, but it points the same way, and it matches what FanGraphs found in its Stance Shifters series: hitters who adjust in one direction hold up better than hitters who go back and forth. Full reversals are rare, too. Of the hitters who changed going into 2025, fewer than one in six undid any of it going into 2026.

So a stance change is not a fix. On average it buys a little bat speed and a little hard contact and costs a little contact, and more than half of the improvement you hear about would have come anyway from a hitter bouncing back from a bad year. The version that works looks like Bauers: a hitter the grade already liked, who picked a direction, kept going in it, and did not give up bat speed or plate discipline to get there. The stance stories worth believing are the ones about hitters who were already good and got to keep betting on themselves. The stance is the part you can see from the upper deck, but it is the least interesting thing about them.

The Short Version

  1. About one in five regulars makes a real stance change every offseason, and they are mostly hitters coming off a bad year, so some bounce-back is built in.

  2. Against similar hitters who did not change, more than half of the improvement disappears. What is left is a trade: about two points of Power+ and 0.3 mph of bat speed for nearly a point more whiff rate, with no real change in Hitting+.

  3. The stance changes that get written about after hot starts beat expectation by 35 points of wOBA. The typical change beat it by six.

  4. Teams do not drive it. Hitters who switched teams changed their stance at the same rate as hitters who stayed, and no organization changes stances more than chance would predict.

  5. Consistency is what separates the good ones. Hitters whose stance moves around the most have the least stable grades, and Bauers, who narrowed his base four years running and held it, is the model.

Get Balls & Sticks in your inbox

Subscribe for free to get new posts by email as soon as they publish.